ON AIR NOW

LISTEN NOW

Weather

cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
62°
Overcast
H 73° L 52°
  • cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
    62°
    Current Conditions
    Cloudy. H 73° L 52°
  • cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
    59°
    Afternoon
    Cloudy. H 73° L 52°
  • cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
    59°
    Evening
    Mostly Cloudy. H 62° L 43°
LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Krmg news on demand

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Krmg traffic on demand

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Krmg weather on demand

00:00 | 00:00

Is mental health care reform the answer to mass shootings?

Trending on Facebook

More popular and trending stories

In the wake of mass shootings like 2011’s Tucson shooting; 2012’s Aurora, Colorado, shootings; the 2013 mass slayings at Sandy Hook Elementary School; and this month's mass murder near U.C. Santa Barbara, there are two issues you can count on to come up. (Via Wikimedia Commons / Steve KarpAlgrVoice of America)

“Saturday’s attack and Jared Loughner’s apparent mental health problems have shown a spotlight on issues surrounding mental health treatment in Arizona.” (Via Democracy Now!)

“If Adam Lanza had a gun safe in his room and all of these guns and ammunition … why was he allowed to possess such things?” (Via CNN)

Mental illness and gun control have become the two dominant parts of the national discussion around mass shootings.

The reaction to Friday’s shooting in California is no different. But while efforts to tighten restrictions on guns have failed, lawmakers are responding to the recent tragedy by focusing on mental health. (Via KSBYYouTube / Elliot Rodger)

>> Read more trending stories

Rep. Tim Murphy of Pennsylvania, a clinical psychologist, is pushing a new bill that would give families greater rights to intervene if they believe their loved one was becoming a threat. (Via C-SPAN)

“These parents knew. The parents of Adam Lanza knew, the parents of Jared Loughner knew something terrible was going wrong, but so often doctors and police would say, ‘Look, we can’t do anything about it until they practically have a knife to their throat or someone else’s.’” (Via CNN)

A competing bill sponsored by Rep. Ron Barber of Arizona seeks to expand federal mental health programs. (Via Office of Rep. Ron Barber)

And California's legislature is working on its own bills linking gun control to mental health. (Via Office of Assemblymember Nancy Skinner)

“Two California lawmakers are working on a law that would create a gun violence restraining order that could be requested by law enforcement, family members and friends.” (Via KABC)

But are these measures really part of the solution? Some psychiatrists say there are inherent problems with making it easier to lock up people with mental health issues.

An op-ed in The New York Times makes the point that, even for trained mental health professionals, it’s not easy to predict who will become violent. “If we can’t reliably identify people who are at risk of committing violent acts, then how can we possibly prevent guns from falling into the hands of those who are likely to kill? … A normal-appearing killer who is quietly planning a massacre can easily evade detection.”

The killer in Friday's rampage, Elliot Rodger, was interviewed by law enforcement last month at the request of his parents. Police determined he was not a threat, something the sheriff said he regrets.

“We certainly wish that we could turn the clock back and maybe change some things, but at the time that the deputies interacted with him, he was able to convince them that he was OK.” (Via CBS)

Typically, authorities can detain someone for mental health reasons only if they present an imminent threat to themselves or others. In light of suggestions to make the rule less strict, mental health advocates remind us there are civil rights issues at play here as well.

A social worker writing for The Atlantic says: “The civil mental health system is set up the way it is now … to protect citizens. … Our history of abuse-ridden mental hospitals where people were indefinitely detained demonstrates how such institutions can operate without strict oversight.”

So while mental health reforms have some bipartisan support, split opinion on their effectiveness and their potential for abuse could make those reforms divisive, as well.

Read More
VIEW COMMENTS

There are no comments yet. Be the first to post your thoughts. or Register.

  • Unable to convince GOP lawmakers to get on board with a plan to overhaul the Obama health law, Republicans in the House decided not to even force a vote on the measure, a major setback for both President Donald Trump and House Speaker Paul Ryan. “This bill is dead,” said Rep. Greg Walden (R-OR), the Chairman of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, who played a central role in cobbling together this plan. 'This bill is dead,' House Energy & Commerce Committee Chairman Walden says — Cristina Marcos (@cimarcos) March 24, 2017 The bill never even came to a vote, as it became obvious that Republicans had nowhere near a majority of lawmakers ready to vote for it. Democrats were more than happy to pile on the GOP legislative debacle. #ObamaCare 1 – #Trumpcare 0. — Rep. Hank Johnson (@RepHankJohnson) March 24, 2017
  • In the end, monolithic opposition by Democrats coupled with opposition from the far right doomed Friday’s vote on the American Health Care Act, the GOP bill that would have repealed and replaced the law commonly known as “Obamacare.” GOP leadership decided to pull the bill, realizing that it could not pass. The Trump administration made it clear early Friday that negotiations were over, and the president wanted an up or down vote Friday. House Speaker Paul Ryan went to the White House to report he didn’t have the votes to pass the bill; President Trump had previously said win or lose, Rep. Ryan should keep his position as Speaker. The GOP plan (AHCA) would have ended the mandate that all Americans pay for health insurance, replacing it with a plan where the federal government would give Americans tax credits, based on age. That would have saved taxpayers billions of dollars, according to the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office, but would have left  24 million additional Americans without health coverage within the next decade. Many governors, including some Republicans, also had serious concerns about the additional burdens passed on to states under the AHCA.
  • The Pawhuska woman recently accused of exposing herself to a classroom of students was arrested this week on accusations of stealing a purse.  According to the arrest report, Lacey Sponsler allegedly stole a purse while at the Broken Arrow Lanes bowling alley near 111th and Elm last Thursday.   The report states that witnesses saw her acting suspiciously and looking at people’s belongings. One witness saw her grab a purse and asked if it was hers. She said it was not.   A witness then reportedly saw Sponsler walk into the game room and return wearing different clothes. Police were called and found her in the bathroom.   Sponsler was arrested in February for doing a cartwheel in front of students at a Pawhuska school. She was not wearing anything under her dress and exposed herself to the students.
  • Authorities in Ohio arrested three people after they discovered the badly decomposed body of a 71-year-old Vietnam veteran in a home, according to multiple reports. >> Read more trending news Deputies with the Tuscarawas County Sheriff’s Office found the body of Bob Harris, 71, after learning that his Social Security debit card was being used despite the fact that he hadn’t been seen for months, WJW reported. The body had decomposed to the point where the remains were mostly skeletal, lying in the living room of a home in Wainwright. The body was kept a short distance from where the home’s residents slept, according to WJW. “It’s a horribly graphic case,” Sheriff Orvis Campbell told TimesReporter.com. He said Harris’ body was found in some “of the most deplorable conditions we can describe.” Trash and animal waste was found near the body. Harris was living with a married couple and their daughter, according to TimesReporter.com. The family had spread stories about Harris moving to Stark County and allowing them to use his Social Security benefits, Campbell said. Authorities arrested Brian and Stacy Sorohan on charges of abuse of a corpse and theft of a credit card, according to The Associated Press. The couple’s 18-year-old daughter was charged with abuse of a corpse. Deputies said the circumstances surrounding Harris’ death were not immediately clear. An autopsy will be performed to determine whether his death involved foul play, according to TimesReporter.com.
  • Tulsa police Thursday released video of an incident in which an officer used his patrol car to end a gunfight. Madison Dickson was the suspect in a string of violent crimes that spanned nearly a week when she was spotted in a vehicle near 91st and Harvard last Saturday. She tried to run, and gunfire is heard on the video, which officers say was directed toward them. The officer swerves left as she points the gun at him, then veers right and runs her over as she attempts to flee. Additional videos released to media by TPD indicate an officer also used a Taser on Dickson after she was down, because she still had the gun and wasn’t responding to commands. “She might not be able to, hang on,” one officer says as others are yelling at her to show her hands. EMSA arrived on the scene a few minutes later, but Dickson died from her injuries.