ON AIR NOW

LISTEN NOW

Weather

cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
73°
Partly Cloudy
H 84° L 63°
  • cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
    73°
    Current Conditions
    Partly Cloudy. H 84° L 63°
  • cloudy-day Created with Sketch.
    84°
    Afternoon
    Partly Cloudy. H 84° L 63°
  • clear-day Created with Sketch.
    84°
    Evening
    Mostly Sunny. H 88° L 64°
LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Krmg news on demand

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Krmg traffic on demand

00:00 | 00:00

LISTEN
PAUSE
ERROR

Krmg weather on demand

00:00 | 00:00

Local
Lawsuits begin against ODOT guardrail manufacturer
Close

Lawsuits begin against ODOT guardrail manufacturer

Lawsuits begin against ODOT guardrail manufacturer
A Trinity ET Plus guardrail after being struck by a drunk driver last May. A former manufacturer tells FOX23 News it was not supposed to bend into a wedge.

Lawsuits begin against ODOT guardrail manufacturer

One out of the nine types of guardrails the Oklahoma Department of Transportation uses across the state is coming under fire for claims by drivers and a former guardrail manufacturer that a design flaw is crippling and even killing drivers.

Drivers and the former manufacturer are suing Dallas-based Trinity Industries for what they say is repeated poor performance issues on the Trinity ET-Plus 4-inch model guardrail that is in place in multiple states and even a few foreign countries.

“I woke up with the guardrail coming through the floor between the brake and the gas pedal,” Jay Traylor said after he fell asleep while driving on I-40 near Raleigh, North Carolina.

Traylor hit an ET-Plus guardrail that folded into a wedge shape on impact, pierced the passenger cabin of his car and severed both of the former Marine’s legs.

In a 911, call Traylor told dispatchers “I’m sorry. They’re not going to make it” when dispatchers asked him to hold on when help was en route.

Traylor made a tourniquet out of his belt and saved his life.

He is now suing Trinity Industries for what he feels is a design flaw.

That was in North Carolina back in January. In May, a drunk driver collided with a Trinity ET-Plus guardrail on Highway 75 near West 41st Street in West Tulsa. The driver hit the guardrail, then the cable barriers separating the north and southbound lanes, and then died in the hospital.

Joshua Harman, oversaw the manufacturing of a similar guardrail to the ET-Plus, and after producing them for three years, he began to notice a pattern in accidents that happened with the guardrail. He ceased production in his factories, replaced the guardrails he felt were faulty, and began to collect evidence across the United States to make the case for a recall.

“They need to understand that this is happening everywhere, and the more this comes to light, the more their voices will be heard, and not just mine,” Harman said.

He showed FOX23 News what he felt were similarities to previous accidents, and the accident that took place last May in West Tulsa.

“What I have seen and witnessed. I'd hit anything else but one of these. These things are not working,” Harman said.

Harman tells FOX23 that in every case he’s documented, the guardrail is not blowing out and stopping the car like a buffer as designed. Instead, the head is failing in mid-collision, causing the rail to bend into a sharp edge that enters the passenger cabin of the car injuring and sometimes killing the driver.

“It defies logic that all of these drivers would intentionally be hitting the four inch model incorrectly in the course of an accident,” Harman said.

FOX23 took Harman’s claims to the Oklahoma Department of Transportation.

“We put layers of protection up to try to help drivers once they leave the roadway,” ODOT Spokeswoman Kenna Carmon said. “Each accident is going to be looked at differently, and each accident we're going to react differently.”

Carmon tells FOX23 News that the guardrail in the Tulsa crash did not enter the car, and tire tracks show the crash is different from what Harmon has documented before.

“It clipped the edge of the guardrail pulling it back before the car came to rest against the cable barrier system,” Carmon said. “So it appears right now that the guardrail performed as expected and did not malfunction.”

Carmon said the ET-Plus meets ODOT standards set by the National Highway Transportation Safety Administration. She also added that because the guardrail diverted the car off the road and into the cable barriers, ODOT considers the guardrail to have done its job by directing the driver of the car off the road and out of harm’s way, on-coming traffic.

Carmon tells FOX23 that Harman has not come to ODOT with his concerns about the recent ET-Plus crash on Highway 75.

Dallas-based manufacturer Trinity Industries sent FOX23 News the following statement:

The ET-Plus® System continues to be accepted by the Federal Highway Administration for use on U.S. highways.  In the case of the lawsuit that has been filed, the trial is slated to take place in July.  Trinity intends to continue defending itself (and the outstanding reputation of Texas A&M) against Mr. Harman’s allegations in court.

[Trinity Industries] continue(s) to have a high degree of confidence in the performance and integrity of the ET-Plus ® System. 

Trinity Industries goes on to say that every crash is unique and should be looked at on a case by case basis and off multiple factors that happened in crash saying:

Without this and other information pertinent to each incident independently, it is impossible to determine how the end terminal system performed. 

A whistleblower lawsuit between Harmon and Trinity will start in July. Harman tells FOX23 he doesn't want money, just a recall.

The Nevada Department of Transportation tells FOX23 it has removed the Trinity ET-Plus guardrail from its approved qualified products list because of an “unauthorized design change” that took place a few years ago.

NDOT goes on to tell FOX23 that ET-Plus guardrails will not be removed from highways in Nevada, but if one needs replacing, it will not be switched out with another Trinity ET-Plus guardrail.

Trinity Industries tells FOX23 is it working to correct the design change issue.

To see  Harman’s findings, he has made all of his information available at failingheads.com

Read More
VIEW COMMENTS

There are no comments yet. Be the first to post your thoughts. or Register.

  • Responding to concerns about personal security for lawmakers after last week’s gun attack at a Congressional baseball practice, U.S. House leaders are moving to provide extra money to members for protection back home, as well as new funding to bolster the work of police and security officials on Capitol Hill. Under a plan approved by a House spending subcommittee on Friday, the Congress would provide an extra $7.5 million next year to the Capitol Police for an “increased security posture” around the Capitol, along with $5 million to the House Sergeant at Arms to help with security for lawmakers back in their districts. “We are taking a new fresh look at security,” said Rep. Kevin Yoder (R-KS), the Chairman of subcommittee that deals with funding for the Legislative Branch. Our FY18 Legislative Branch funding bill increases efficiency & transparency in Congress, enhances security for Members & our constituents. pic.twitter.com/FI36tF2XeH — Rep. Kevin Yoder (@RepKevinYoder) June 22, 2017 “The tragic events of June 14 weigh heavily on these deliberations,” said Rep. Rodney Frelinghuysen (R-NJ), the Chairman of the House Appropriations Committee, which could vote on the extra money as early as this next week. Also being put into motion is a separate plan to funnel an extra $25,000 to each member of the House – about $11 million in all – to help them increase security back in their districts. “The scariest part for us is there used to be this impression by the public that we all had security everywhere we went,” said Rep. Tim Ryan (D-OH). “Now, everyone knows that isn’t the case,” Ryan added, as he lent his support to the extra funding for security as well. The money in this budget bill would not take effect until the new fiscal year – which starts October 1 – so, House leaders are ready to okay extra money immediately for members worried about security back in their districts. Roll Call newspaper reported that could be approved in coming days by the House Administration Committee. Yoder said Congressional leaders are also waiting to see if money raised in campaign contributions for House elections could be put to use for security as well. “Pending an FEC (Federal Election Commission) decision, we’re also looking at whether campaign funds could be used to continue to support security upgrades at personal residences,” Yoder added.
  • An unknown aged girl went to the hospital with burns to her legs, following an overnight house fire. KRMG’s told the fire started around 2:40 a.m., at a residence on West 50th Court North. The homeowner says he was able to get his daughter, grand daughter and sleeping brother out of the house. So far, firefighters haven't released a cause for the fire.  The homeowner believes fumes from a gas can in the garage may have cause the blaze.   
  • Multiple people had to be rescued early Saturday morning in Rogers County. OTEMS paramedics report a boat started to sink on Oologah Lake just after midnight. “Additional information was received that the boat had its nose in the air, four individuals were in the water, and only one was wearing a PDF (personal flotation device),” an official said. “A Rogers County Deputy spotted what might be the boat south of Winganon Bridge but was unable to determine the precise location. However it was located by the Northwest Water Rescue unit and at 0048 hours the rescue boat reported that it had located the victims and was loading the fourth individual into the boat.” KRMG’s told the victims were hanging onto the hull when they were found. So far, no injuries have been reported.  Officials also haven’t released any names.   We do know the Oklahoma Highway Patrol has taken over the investigation.  
  • Tulsa investigators are looking for a driver who fled the scene, after hitting a male pedestrian late Friday night. Police report the auto-pedestrian collision happened around 11:34 p.m., near East Admiral and North Yale. “The pedestrian victim has been declared deceased at this time,” police said.   Investigators don't have a description of the driver or the car.  Anyone with information regarding the incident is asked to call Crime Stoppers at 918-596-COPS.
  • We know this might start an argument, but according to Business Insider, Oklahoma's most famous band EVER is the Flaming Lips. Business Insider admits the song 'She Don't Use Jelly' is the Norman-based indie rockers only U.S. hit. But they say the band has had many hits in the U.K. and Europe and, even more impressive, three Grammys to their credit. Some on the list are hard to argue with, like Bruce Springsteen and the E-Street Band in New Jersey or Nirvana in Washington State. You can see the entire list of the most famous bands here.